Modern white-stucco home with black-framed windows, a recessed oak entry and a planted concrete garden approach.

Why Coronado's Free Summer Shuttle Carried Fewer Riders but Still Left People at the Curb

How does a free bus run 30 more days than the year before, carry fewer people in total, and still pull away from stops with riders left on the sidewalk? The city's own report on the season, presented to the City Council on Nov. 3, shows that the 9% ridership drop came from cuts to the buses. Demand didn't fall.

The difference matters beyond one summer. Council is weighing the summer shuttle and a revived Island Express on-demand service at the same time, and both decisions turn on what the 2026 numbers actually measured.

What changed on Route 904 before the first ride

The free summer shuttle replaces MTS Route 904 with free, more frequent service, and the city has funded it every summer since 2013 except 2020. In 2026 it ran daily from June 7 to September 7, 9 a.m. to 8 p.m.

Two changes came before the season started. In January 2026, MTS replaced the 40-foot buses on Route 904 with 35-foot mini-buses that run on liquid propane gas. The new buses have 20 fixed seats and no room for standees, while the old ones had 32 to 40 seats plus standing room. The 2026 program also cut service from four buses to three, so a bus came every 20 minutes instead of every 15.

The staff report's season figures show the effect:

2025 season 2026 season
Service days 63 93
Buses circulating 4 3
Minutes between buses 15 20
Total passengers 70,585 64,019
Passengers per day 1,123 688
Average passengers per trip 12.5 10.5
MTS bus service cost $114,004 $103,371
Cost per passenger $1.62 $1.58

The 2025 season had been the program's comeback. After the 2023 bus workers' strike pushed ridership down to 34,248, Council shortened the season in 2024 and called 2025 the shuttle's last try. Coronado Times reported that 2025 brought the highest daily ridership since the pandemic and the third highest in the program's history. The 2019 peak was 154,026 riders over 102 days.

So the 2026 season ran half again as many days on a smaller bus that came less often. City staff wrote that the drop in passengers "was expected as a result of a reduction in capacity and trips per day."

Why half-empty buses still filled up

An average of 10.5 riders on a 20-seat bus sounds like plenty of room. That average spreads the morning and evening trips across the busiest part of the day. The report says ridership stayed above 60 passengers an hour from 11 a.m. to 6 p.m., with fewer riders at the start and end of the day.

Over the full season, the seat limit turned riders away. MTS counted 242 trips that hit full capacity and at least 653 passengers who couldn't board the bus they were waiting for. Staff added that the ridership totals leave out "potential passengers that were lost due to the reduced passenger capacity," so the 64,019 figure counts people who got on, not people who wanted to.

The season's stop totals show where the demand is concentrated. The southbound stop at 1st Street and B Avenue, next to the Ferry Landing, led every other stop on the route. The northbound stop at Orange and Adella Avenues came second. Staff read this as most passengers riding between those two points. The Coronado News reported more than 15,000 boardings at the Ferry Landing stop, against about 8,700 at Orange and Adella.

The smaller buses also changed who could ride comfortably. In the city's rider survey, 77% of the 208 respondents rated their ride good or excellent. The 9% who called it awful pointed to full buses, no service to the Coronado Cays, and mini-buses that were harder to use with strollers and wheelchairs and for seniors. Seniors 65 and older made up 48% of respondents. Coronado residents were the largest group at 52%, followed by out-of-state visitors at 26%.

Where adding capacity didn't fix the problem

If the curb problem came only from seats, adding a bus should have solved it. The two busiest weekends of the summer pointed in different directions.

For NASCAR weekend, June 19 to 21, MTS put a fourth bus on the route. Ridership went down. The three days carried 1,619 passengers, fewer than the weekend before at 1,881 and the weekend after at 2,003. Over Fourth of July weekend, July 3 to 5, the fourth bus ran again. This time ridership rose as expected, to 2,787 passengers on the Village route, and Village service on July 4 ran from 8 a.m. to 10:30 p.m.

The Fourth of July shuttle between the Coronado Cays Fire Station and the Coronado Community Center ran every 30 minutes from a 7:30 a.m. first pickup to an 11 p.m. last drop-off. It carried 498 riders, down from 949 in 2025. Staff attributed the drop to fewer trips and less capacity.

For the rest of the summer, the city's Cays plan relied on PRONTO passes so Cays residents could ride a regular MTS bus to the shuttle at the Community Center. The pass numbers from 2026:

  • 460 passes purchased, at a cost of $2,680
  • 374 distributed to 52 Coronado Cays households, with six households claiming between 12 and 20 passes each
  • 81 actually used, the first year MTS could track usage
  • 86 left in the city's inventory for a future season
  • None picked up by residents of Liberty Military Housing, which was eligible for the first time

Taken together, the Village route ran short on seats during peak hours, and the Cays connection had more capacity than riders used. A larger bus would only address the first of those.

What Council heard on Nov. 3

The report was on the Nov. 3 consent calendar with the recommendation to "receive report and provide direction as appropriate." The Coronado News' account of the meeting described Council's interest in exploring electric vehicles for the shuttle.

Councilmember Carrie Anne Downey defended the smaller buses, according to the paper: "Some people are saying maybe we shouldn't keep the small sizes, but I think those have helped in a lot of ways, in terms of keeping it more efficient and therefore (bringing) price per person down. Getting the larger buses back wouldn't necessarily solve the 653 passenger issue." The same report said Councilmember Kelly Purvis had watched riders who couldn't board wait for the next bus or walk a couple of blocks to another stop.

The efficiency case shows up in the budget. The full 2026 program cost $105,124, below the $117,094 estimate. That total includes $103,371 for MTS bus service, $2,680 for PRONTO passes and $513 for marketing, offset by $1,440 in ad revenue. Even so, cost per passenger fell only from $1.62 to $1.58, because the smaller service also carried fewer people.

Electric buses aren't coming soon from the transit agency. Beverly Neff, MTS's manager of planning and reporting, told Council, "We have slowed down on the EV purchases just because those vehicles are so much more expensive and have much more limited range. It is not a current priority due to the fiscal issues that we're in," The Coronado News reported.

The second shuttle decision, coming back early next year

Council had asked for the 2026 shuttle numbers before deciding something bigger. On Oct. 20 it voted unanimously to hold off on a contract for an all-electric, on-demand shuttle to succeed the 2024 Island Express pilot, Coronado Times reported. Members said they wanted to review the summer shuttle's 2026 ridership first, and the matter is expected back in early 2027.

The pilot's own numbers explain why the decision has taken this long. Circuit ran the Island Express free to riders from June to December 2024. It carried 58,596 passengers, 52,945 in the Village and 5,651 in the Cays, at a cost to the city of $561,509. A Cays ride averaged $29 per passenger, against about $7 in the Village.

City staff recommended negotiating with Via, through Crosby Street Transit LLC, for year-round on-demand service in the Village, using either electric vans or the Polaris GEM carts that became the Island Express's look. GEMs can't legally drive on State Route 75, so the Cays would get its own optional service: two wheelchair-accessible vans on a five-stop fixed route every 30 minutes. The Village service would cost about $980,000 in its first year and $860,000 a year after that. The Cays service would cost $455,000 the first year and $360,000 after. Those figures don't count fares or ads.

Possible offsets reported by Coronado Times:

  • Fares, from flat fares to fares at half the average ride cost, with reduced fares for residents, seniors or students
  • Advertising, in the app, on in-vehicle screens and on rooftops, with the city keeping all of the revenue
  • A SANDAG Flexible Fleets grant, which the SANDAG transportation committee did not recommend for funding, with the full board yet to decide
  • $300,000 that Discover Coronado set aside from its reserves for community projects

Mayor John Duncan framed the question as how much the city should spend beyond what riders pay back. He said he wants public input on whether the program is worth $600,000 to $800,000 a year in taxpayer money. "My goal is to create a program that is not going to fail," Duncan said. Downey brought her own framework: year-round service, three electric carts for door-to-door Village rides, rotating vans serving four set pickup points in the Cays such as Cays Park and the Coronado Cays Yacht Club, riders paying half their trip cost, a $1 discount for residents, and service until 11 p.m. on Fridays and Saturdays.

The two shuttles are now being judged on the same numbers. Council members have asked in past meetings whether running both a fixed-route summer shuttle and an on-demand service would be redundant. The 2026 season gives each side something to point to. The busiest leg ran between the Ferry Landing and Orange and Adella, and the Cays passes went mostly unused. In the city's survey, 62% of riders said they would have driven or taken other motorized transportation without the shuttle. As Coronado Times put it, parking in the Village "remains a battle."

How you get from the Ferry Landing to Orange Avenue on a summer afternoon affects daily life in Coronado more than any listing photo shows. If you're thinking about how the Village's parking and transit fit your plans for a Coronado home, the team at Fine Properties San Diego can walk you through it block by block. Request a Complimentary Market Valuation, and we'll start with the part of the island you use most.

Work With Us

At Fine Properties San Diego, we consider it a privilege to collaborate with clients and guide them through one of life’s most meaningful journeys – buying or selling a home. Our commitment to service excellence and unparalleled local expertise set us apart. The opportunity to turn dreams into keys is our passion – let’s connect!

Follow Me on Instagram